Skip to content
When your auditor suspects fraud: what happens next
Audit

When your auditor suspects fraud: what happens next

What the law makes your auditor do on suspecting employee fraud, the deadlines that follow, and how a board should respond in the first week.

Every year, the directors of a company sign a statement that they took proper care to prevent and detect fraud. Most boards never test what happens when that statement is challenged. If the auditor comes to suspect that an officer or employee has defrauded the company, the law starts a clock that the board cannot stop. What the board does in the next few days decides how much is recovered and what goes on the public record.

What the law requires

The duty sits on the auditor, not the company. It applies when the auditor, while doing the audit, has reason to believe that an officer or employee is committing or has committed fraud in the company. What happens next depends on the amount.

Fraud of ₹1 crore or moreFraud below ₹1 crore
First reportTo the Board or Audit Committee, within 2 days of the auditor knowingTo the Audit Committee or Board, within 2 days of the auditor knowing
Company's responseThe Board or Audit Committee has 45 days to replyNo reply period is set
Report to the Central GovernmentWithin 15 days of the reply, with the reply and the auditor's comments. Filed electronically in Form ADT-4Not required
If the company stays silentThe auditor files anyway, noting that no reply cameNot applicable
Disclosure by the companyNone under this ruleThe Board's report must give the nature of the fraud, the approximate amount, the remedial action taken, and the parties involved if remedial action has not been taken

Two more requirements sit beside this. The same duty applies to a company's cost auditor and secretarial auditor. And where the Companies (Auditor's Report) Order, 2020 applies, the audit report itself must say whether any fraud by or on the company was noticed or reported in the year, whether a Form ADT-4 was filed, and whether the auditor considered whistle-blower complaints.

Five things about this rule that surprise boards

  1. The trigger is belief, not proof. The auditor must act on "reason to believe". The two days run from the auditor's knowledge, not from the end of an investigation. Asking the auditor to wait until the company has finished its own inquiry does not pause anything.
  2. The board cannot block the report. The board's reply travels with the report. If the board says nothing for 45 days, the report is filed without it. The 45 days are the company's one chance to put its own account on the record.
  3. The amount is an estimate. The ₹1 crore test covers a fraud that "involves or is expected to involve" that sum. A loss that looks small on day one can cross the line once the full period is examined.
  4. Small frauds do not stay private. Below ₹1 crore nothing goes to the government, but the details go into the Board's report that shareholders receive with the accounts. If the company has not taken remedial action, the report must also name the parties involved.
  5. Only insiders are covered, and it may not matter who noticed first. The duty covers fraud by officers and employees. A fraud by a vendor or customer alone falls outside it, though the audit report still has to mention any fraud on the company. On who noticed first, there are two views. ICAI's guidance note took the position that the auditor need not report a fraud that management had already found and was dealing with. A circular issued by the National Financial Reporting Authority in June 2023 says the auditor must report even then, and that resigning does not remove the duty. Companies whose auditors fall under that authority should plan on the stricter reading.

One fact explains why auditors do not bend on any of this. An auditor who fails to report faces a fixed penalty of ₹5 lakh for a listed company and ₹1 lakh for any other. An auditor who reports in good faith is protected by the Act.

Good practiceThe first week

This section is professional judgement, not a legal requirement.

  1. Put the right person in charge. The response should be led by the Audit Committee chair or an independent director. It should not be led by the head of the function where the fraud happened. Anyone who might be implicated steps aside from the inquiry, whatever their seniority.
  2. Preserve before you confront. Secure emails, accounting system logs, access records and company devices first. Remove the person's system access quietly. Once a suspect is confronted, anything not yet secured is at risk.
  3. Stop the loss without touching the records. Hold payments to linked vendors and change approval rights. Do not correct, reverse or tidy any entry. The records are evidence in the state they are in.
  4. Size it early and write down how. Because the legal test is the expected amount, the estimate decides which route applies. Record the period covered, the method and the assumptions, and share them with the auditor.
  5. Do not settle quietly. Letting the person resign and repay can look like the practical answer. It does not switch off the auditor's duty or the disclosure in the Board's report. It also leaves the company unable to show what it did.
  6. Use the 45 days. Reply with facts: what was found, who is investigating, what has been recovered, and which controls have changed. A reply that argues with the auditor and offers no facts reads badly when it reaches the government attached to the auditor's comments.
  7. Check who else must be told. A listed company has to disclose a fraud by the company, its promoter, a director, a key managerial person, senior management or a subsidiary to the stock exchanges within 24 hours. Any company should read its insurance policy and loan agreements, which often carry their own notice periods.

Good practiceWhat to settle before it ever happens

Two days is too short to decide these things for the first time. This section is also professional judgement, except where a rule is named.

  • A one-page response plan. It names who receives the auditor's report, who leads, who speaks to the auditor, and which outside lawyer and investigator can be called the same day.
  • A complaint channel that reaches someone independent. The law requires a vigil mechanism for listed companies, companies that accept public deposits, and companies with bank or financial institution borrowings above ₹50 crore. Other companies can adopt one by choice. Keep a log of every complaint and its outcome, because the auditor is required to consider whistle-blower complaints.
  • A known retention period for data. Find out how long emails, system logs and CCTV footage are kept. A fraud that ran for three years cannot be measured with six months of logs.
  • An early-warning habit with the auditor. Tell the auditor about a serious allegation when it arises, not at the year-end. An auditor who learns of it late has less time and less reason to trust the company's account.

Frequently asked questions

Does this apply to a small private company?

Yes. Section 143(12) speaks of the auditor of "a company" and sets no size limit. Only the route changes with the amount.

What does the person who committed the fraud face?

Under Section 447, where the fraud involves at least ₹10 lakh or one per cent of turnover, whichever is lower, the punishment is imprisonment from six months to ten years, and a fine of at least the amount involved and up to three times that amount. Where public interest is involved, the minimum term is three years. For a smaller fraud with no public interest, it is imprisonment up to five years, a fine up to ₹50 lakh, or both.

Is the auditor required to look for fraud in every transaction?

No. The duty arises from what the auditor comes across "in the course of the performance of his duties as auditor". It is a duty to report what the audit reveals, not a guarantee that every fraud will be found.

This article is for general information and is not professional advice.

Keep reading